Close

December 18, 2018

WordPress Gutenberg is AWFUL compared to the classic editor

I got this comment yesterday on a Gutenberg video of mine:

“Anybody who knows HTML/CSS hates the damn thing. They should have incrementally introduced it.  Personally, I think it sucks. All the assumed functionality is has been removed.”

And I asked him:

“Compared to the Classic Editor?”

And he responded:

“Yes…I love the concept but the layout and how it works is not intuitive. This, in my opinion, is a fail. I’m sure it’s better. I just hate it.”

I honestly don’t get it.

What can you do in the Classic Editor that you can’t in Gutenberg?

Like, if you just wanna type a blog post like you did in the old editor, you can 100% do that. And, your experience will be almost exactly the same. Adding images is easier, IMO. And, there’s far more options now in Gutenberg for layouts, etc.

No, it’s not perfect.

But, compared to the Classic Editor?

It’s just not even close.

As for the rollout…

Mullenweg was talking about Gutenberg at least as early as the summer of 2017. There’s been a Gutenberg plugin out for almost a year and a half. If this took you by surprise, it’s the slowest-moving “curve ball” you’ll ever see.

So yeah…

Call me crazy, but I don’t get it.

The only way it seems you can call Gutenberg “crap” is if you compare it to other page-builders like Elementor or Divi, etc. Okay… but it’s just NOT one of those things right now. It’s a post editor.

And, in that sense it’s a massive improvement.

But whatever…

You do you.

You’ll be using Gutenberg soon enough.

It always happens.

And, there’s a lesson in that. 

People are horrible at “predicting” what technology they’ll use. How many people said the internet was dumb and they’d never use it? Smartphones? Social media? And, how many of those people ARE now using all of those things?

And, so it goes.

If you can predict this stuff, you can get ahead of the curve.

Get an advantage over everyone “swearing” they’ll never use XYZ.

Build products and services.

Out-compete those who get left behind.

Etc.

You just gotta have the guts to assess things for yourself.

And, not always follow the tide of what people “think”.

In any case, if you’re just ready to do that with Gutenberg, dive in and learn this thing and don’t want to learn yet another piece of software on your own, then check out my Beginner’s Guide to WordPress Gutenberg course on SkillShare.

Here’s some early reviews in case you’re wondering if it’s any good:

“John is so well-spoken and his passion for web development definitely peaks through. This class really helps the transition from the classic WP post/page editing to Gutenberg block editing. Thank you John, I feel confident tackling my first project using Gutenberg.”

— Karen Butler

“Excellent course for getting started with WordPress Gutenberg editor.”

— Jane D

“This course is the ‘JIT’! – Just In Time for the release of WordPress 5.0 featuring the new Gutenberg editor. The course is great for all levels of users wanting to get their feets wet and start learning how to use Gutenberg inside of WordPress. John (as always) does a superb job of covering the topic content with enough depth and breadth to let you get in there and make something useful. Thanks John!”

— Mark Zup

So, there you go.

Link to get no-cost access to the course is here: https://skl.sh/2AQpjNj

Later,

John​​​​​​​

6 Comments on “WordPress Gutenberg is AWFUL compared to the classic editor

patachilles
January 7, 2019 at 12:29 pm

I just switched over to Gutenberg but I do not see how I can link the publishing of a new blog post to Twitter, LinkedIn & FB – do you know how that’s done? It was easy on the classic editor, it was in a box down the right hand side of the screen. Where is that function now?

Reply
J Carter
February 20, 2019 at 12:05 pm

Yeah, going to have to disagree with you on just about everything you wrote. Gutenberg is WAY harder to use, brings nothing to the table, and is clunky as hell. And no, I won’t be using Gutenberg soon enough.

Reply
John Morris
February 23, 2019 at 10:49 pm

What’s way harder to use? Don’t see that. There’s a bunch of new blocks you’d have needed plugins and their shortcodes for… just built into the editor now. Reusable blocks, alone, is worth the switch. And, yes you will. You’ll see.

Reply
Rod Woolfolk
March 1, 2019 at 7:39 pm

I hate Gutenberg WordPress Editor. Plus they are trying to make it the default. It’s terrible. Classic Mode is a way better. Gutenberg is for people that don’t know anything about HTML or CSS. Let those people use WIX. WordPress is for people that know their way around style sheet.

Reply
Free Sandwiches (@freesandwichs)
April 22, 2019 at 4:33 pm

Gutenberg sucks. 100% sucks. Nothing is easier, most things are clunky. Integration with old standby themes and plugins is horrendously bad. Beginning of the end for WordPress.

Reply
anothercreativeagency
April 26, 2019 at 8:31 pm

The fact that you cannot nest elements in Gutenberg is enough for me to write it off. Additionally the fact that Gutenberg doesn’t use semantically correct HTML5 (sections, articles, etc) is also incredibly frustrating.

I have a feeling Gutenberg will be excellent when parent sections, proper HTML5, and nested elements are working and streamlined. As of right now its easier to hardcore a website than use Gutenberg.

Reply

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.